Daniel J. Thomasch, a litigation partner in Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher’s New York office, represents clients in complex, high-value cases across a broad range of practice areas and industries.
Mr. Thomasch is a Fellow of the American College of Trial Lawyers, and currently serves as Chair of the College’s Federal Rules of Evidence Committee. He has tried cases to verdict in federal and state courts in New York, Delaware, Maryland, Virginia, Tennessee, Florida, Colorado, Texas and Nebraska, and has argued appeals in the United States Courts of Appeal for the Second, Third, Sixth, Ninth, Eleventh and Federal Circuits, and in the highest courts of New York, Georgia and Maryland. Mr. Thomasch is regularly asked to assume lead responsibility for ongoing matters after unfavorable pre-trial rulings or other developments have increased the stakes of the litigation and/or diminished the likelihood of success at trial. He has a record of consistent success in those situations.
Lawdragon has ranked Mr. Thomasch as among the “Top 500 Lawyers” and as one of the “500 Leading Litigators.” Chambers USA: America’s Leading Lawyers for Business repeatedly ranks Mr. Thomasch nationally for Product Liability and Mass Torts, and in New York for Intellectual Property. Chambers notes that he “is an outstanding litigator,” and “very strategic, very smart and extremely good on his feet in court.” Benchmark Litigation: The Definitive Guide to America’s Leading Litigation Firms and Attorneys named Mr. Thomasch a “Litigation Star” nationally for Product Liability and in the State of New York for Commercial Litigation, and he has twice been recommended in the Who’s Who Legal Product Liability Defence guide. The Best Lawyers in America© named Mr. Thomasch a leading attorney for Product Liability Litigation, and Law & Politics has named him “A Super Lawyer” every year since 2006 for product liability defense and/or intellectual property litigation. He is recommended for “Life Sciences: Product Liability” in PLC’s Which Lawyer?, was named an “IP Star” by Managing Intellectual Property magazine, and designated a “Life Sciences Star” in the inaugural publication of LMG Life Sciences 2012, and in each subsequent issue. Mr. Thomasch is ranked by IAM Patent 1000 in patent litigation.
Mr. Thomasch serves on the Steering Committee of the Defense Research Institute’s Drug and Medical Device Committee. He is a member of the American Bar Association, the American Intellectual Property Law Association, the New York Intellectual Property Law Association, the Federal Bar Council and The Association of the Bar of the City of New York (Thurgood Marshall Award, 1998).
Mr. Thomasch received his J.D. from Columbia University School of Law in 1981, where he was a Harlan Fiske Stone Scholar and recipient of the Young B. Smith Award. His undergraduate degree is from Northwestern University. After law school, Mr. Thomasch was a law clerk to the Honorable Thomas P. Griesa of the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York.
The following is a representative sample of Mr. Thomasch’s cases.*
Litigation for Big-Four Accounting Firms
- Fraud and Breach of Contract: Mr. Thomasch is lead counsel for PwC and multiple individuals in an action brought in California Superior Court by the City of Los Angeles (“City”) alleging fraudulent inducement and breach of contract in the implementation of a new Customer Information System for the City’s Department of Water and Power (LADWP). During discovery, Mr. Thomasch and his team uncovered evidence that the City’s counsel had perpetrated a massive fraud on the Court in a related case, in order to facilitate the City’s efforts to blame PwC falsely for problems with LADWP’s new billing system. That evidence forced LADWP’s highest ranking employee to resign; that individual then pleaded the Fifth Amendment at his deposition, as did lead counsel for the City and lead counsel for the plaintiff class in the related case. As was widely reported in newspapers and other media, the FBI thereafter raided the offices of LADWP and the City Attorney. In addition to the on-going federal investigation, the trial court appointed a Special Master to investigate the City’s wrongdoing. Faced with an array of adverse rulings by the trial court, the City dismissed with prejudice all claims against PwC and the individual defendants. PwC has informed the Court that it will be filing a motion for sanctions against the City.
- Wage and Hour Class Actions: As lead trial and appellate counsel for PwC in multiple wage-and-hour class actions, Mr. Thomasch argued and won in the Ninth Circuit an appeal of an issue of first impression under the California Labor Code, obtaining reversal of the District Court’s summary adjudication in favor of a class of approximately 2,000 unlicensed accountants.
- ERISA: Mr. Thomasch currently represents PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP (“PwC”) in a high-stakes ERISA class action pending in the Southern District of New York, in which Plaintiffs seek to compel payment of “whipsaw claims” exceeding $1 billion.
- Arbitration of Misrepresentation Claims: As lead counsel for a Big Four accounting firm, Mr. Thomasch successfully moved the New York Supreme Court to compel arbitration of a threshold issue in New York, and to stay a complaint alleging fraudulent misrepresentations and omissions filed against the firm in Superior Court of California, County of Los Angeles. The California plaintiff appealed that ruling, and the appeal is pending before the Appellate Division.
Product Liability and Mass Torts
- Wyeth: Served as national lead trial and appellate counsel in nearly 400 product liability cases involving claims that childhood vaccines containing the preservative thimerosal caused autism in vaccinated children, prevailing in every case. Successfully tried a two-week Frye hearing in which Wyeth attacked all causation theories purporting to link vaccines to autism, resulting in the exclusion of all of plaintiffs’ expert witnesses. Argued the appeal to Maryland’s highest court and obtained a unanimous affirmance, which effectively adopted a new standard for the admissibility of expert testimony in civil cases, Blackwell Wyeth, 408 Md. 575, 971 A.2d 235 (2009). That decision resulted in the dismissal of the claims of all of the approximately 300 plaintiffs in cases then-pending against vaccine manufacturers in Maryland. Devised federal preemption strategy that ultimately resulted in the successful conclusion of the national litigation, and argued preemption motions and appeals in state and federal courts, leading to the Supreme Court’s decision in Bruesewitz v. Wyeth, in which the Court held that all design defect claims involving recommended childhood vaccines are preempted by the National Childhood Vaccine Injury Act of 1986.*
- Breg, Inc.: As appellate counsel, obtained reversal of intentional concealment verdict in the California Court of Appeal, resulting in vacatur of a significant punitive damages award and a dramatic reduction in compensatory damages.
- American Home Products Corporation: First-chaired and won the first jury trial of a case involving alleged neurological injuries from the use of the Norplant System, a contraceptive implant, obtaining a complete defense verdict. Obtained dismissal of numerous cases involving prescription drugs, biologics, medical devices and OTC products, through successful motion practice.*
- The Dow Chemical Company: Obtained dismissal of claims brought on behalf of up to thousands of Brazilian citizens seeking damages under the Alien Tort Statute and state law for alleged injuries from environmental contamination. In another case, Mr. Thomasch obtained dismissal of state law claims brought by more than 300 residents of Ecuador alleging personal injuries from exposure to a commercial fungicide used on banana crops.*
- American Cyanamid Company: Successfully defended litigation initiated by the City of New York to recover for property damage and personal injuries alleged to have resulted from exposure to lead pigment-in-paint manufactured by a putative predecessor-in-interest to Cyanamid.*
- Lederle Laboratories: First-chaired and won three multi-week jury trials of cases involving permanent injuries to infants allegedly resulting from immunization with the whole-cell DTP vaccine. Argued and won the resulting appeals in the United States Courts of Appeal for the Second, Sixth and Eleventh Circuits.*
- Lederle Laboratories: Obtained summary judgment prior to class certification of a statewide consumer class action involving a popular multi-vitamin, Caltrate®.*
- Counseling: Mr. Thomasch counsels corporate clients on potential product liability risks arising out of the introduction of new products to market or the acquisition of product manufacturers or specific product lines.
- U.S. Mobile Phone Carrier: Trial and appellate counsel in a patent infringement jury trial in the District of Nebraska. After a multi-week trial, the jury returned a complete defense verdict, finding that all five accused networks to did not infringe any of the six asserted patent claims. On appeal, the Federal Circuit dismissed Plaintiff’s appeal as moot based on its conclusion that the asserted patents recited patent-ineligible subject matter under 35 U.S.C. § 101, as argued by Mr. Thomasch on the carrier’s cross-appeal.
- U.S. Mobile Phone Carrier: Obtained a defense verdict of non-infringement and invalidity on all asserted claims in a jury trial in the Eastern District of Texas, after obtaining pre-trial Daubert rulings dramatically limiting plaintiff’s damages claim.
- Lawson Software: Lead trial counsel for defendant in a civil contempt case following a plaintiff’s verdict of patent infringement and the entry of a permanent injunction by the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia. Developed trial and appellate strategies for the contempt proceedings that resulted in a complete victory on the contempt charge and vacatur of the underlying injunction.
- Dow AgroSciences (DAS): Served for more than a decade as lead national trial and appellate counsel on all patent infringement actions against DAS involving patents for making genes and inserting them into plants to make the plants insect-resistant. Devised and implemented a global litigation strategy that successfully defended (through trial verdicts, summary judgment rulings, voluntary dismissals and appellate rulings) DAS’s core business in multiple interrelated patent litigations throughout the United States. Mr. Thomasch first-chaired and won a bet-the-company jury trial in the District of Delaware in which DAS prevailed against a competitor asserting patent claims that were alleged to cover all transgenic corn products, both commercial and pre-market, in the United States. He won a qui tam suit against DAS in which plaintiff alleged false marking under 35 U.S.C. § 292. Mr. Thomasch also argued appeals before the Federal Circuit in multiple cases involving patents asserted by and against DAS, and DAS prevailed in each such appeal.*
- Alcon Laboratories: Successfully defended Alcon in multiple patent litigations involving prescription drugs used for lowering intraocular pressure in patients suffering from glaucoma, including summary judgment in a case of first impression involving method claims and alleged off-label uses of prescription drugs; argued and won appeal of that ruling in the Federal Circuit.*
- Storz Ophthalmics Company: Obtained dismissal of multiple patent infringement actions involving the design of intraocular lenses and methods for their surgical implantation.*
- Praxis Biologics, Inc.: Successfully defended American Cyanamid Company and Praxis Biologics, Inc. at trial in a patent infringement action related to human infant vaccines against bacterial infections such as meningitis. Trial verdict upheld on appeal to the Federal Circuit.*
- American Cyanamid Company: Lead trial counsel in two bench trials in the District of Colorado arising out of an inventorship dispute with associated claims for copyright infringement and common law torts.*
Insurance Coverage Litigation
- Wyeth: Served as lead counsel in numerous insurance coverage litigations in which the policyholder sought payment of defense costs incurred in the defense of mass tort litigation, and defense and remediation costs for scores of environmental clean-up sites throughout the country. Obtained hundreds of millions of dollars of coverage in highly favorable settlements. Thomasch has also successfully litigated business interruption claims, claims for coverage under D&O policies and reinsurance disputes.*
- John Wyeth & Brother: Served as lead counsel in an insurance coverage action over defense costs incurred by Wyeth in the defense of Benzodiazepine product liability litigation. Worked closely with barrister and instructing solicitors in the successful trial of Wyeth’s claims in the Commercial Court of London.*
Other Litigation and Counseling
- Mr. Thomasch has also litigated criminal and civil antitrust, securities, RICO, breach of contract, fraud, trade secret misappropriation, breach of fiduciary duty, and replevin cases.
*Representations occurred prior to attorney’s affiliation with Gibson Dunn.